Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

By Tim Butler | Posted at 12:52

I tweeted this article about the severe implications of the government's request for a backdoor in Apple's products and included the comment “Imagine the 1st missionary killed in a hostile land, found via an FBI mandated backdoor. This is why Apple is right.” A friend of mine asked me on Facebook why it is so crucial Apple not be forced to create a system that would allow the unlocking of the San Bernardino terror suspect's phone. I want to answer my friend's question by exploring two different parts of the problem.

To understand where this all starts, it starts with Apple creating an encryption system that they did not have the key to unlock. After the revelations about the NSA that Edward Snowden released, Apple created such a system for a very simple reason: it became clear that the government intended to vastly exceed its constitutional surveillance powers and the only way a company like Apple could avoid becoming a collaborator was to remove itself from the key equation so that it genuinely could not access customer data. If a company has the key, the government can demand the key not only to see what a terrorist has on his or her phone, but also for other, less desirable searches like the warrantless, broad data collection the NSA has been doing over the last decade. Worse, when the government utilizes these unconstitutional powers, it imposes gag orders on the companies it interacts with so they cannot even say anything about what is happening.

It bears repeating: while there is broad support for breaking into a terrorist's phone, the only way Apple can legally avoid being made a tool for the government against all of us, not just terrorists, is to create a product that does not have a backdoor. So, Apple did the logical thing: it created a product without any backdoors. Apple is now being asked not just to “unlock” its phone, but to create a new version of its software that has an intentionally broken security system. If it exists, even if it were installed on only this one phone, we will be only a few secret FISA orders away from it being installed on thousands or millions of phones. If an iOS variant that creates a vulnerability exists, the NSA can just contact Apple six months from now and order that same backdoor be included in every iOS device the next time a software update goes out. And, it could gag Apple so that the company could not warn anyone.

Consider how much data the average smart phone has: it knows where we have walked to and driven to, it knows whom we call and write and much of what we say. Most recent phones can listen for us to activate them with a command like “Hey, Siri” or “OK, Google,” which means they essentially listen to everything we do. Add a fitness tracker or smart watch and they know when we sleep, how much exercise we get, even what our vital signs are.

Consider a not so far fetched example: what if, as part of trying to predict crime using Big Data, the government wanted to know where everyone was and if their heart rate had increased, because we assume that someone near a likely crime location with an increased heart rate might be perpetrating a crime? It would be doable with modern smartphones that had government mandated backdoors, but obviously it would shed any modicum of privacy we might still think we have. Think about that for a moment and it becomes clear why we want the data on our phones to be encrypted in a way that only we, the creator of the information, can ever decrypt.

There is even a good, “patriotic,” economic reason to be concerned. If American devices all could have government mandated weakened security on them, it would kill Apple and other American electronics manufacturers overseas. Who wants to buy an Apple product in, say, Germany if it might have been modified by order of the CIA to have that modified software?

Let's say, though, I take an entirely non-cynical approach. I assume the American government always wants to do the right thing and that giving it what it wants here will not lead to any abuses of power on its part. The second issue is the one the article I linked to identifies. If Apple creates a backdoor and activates it even on this one phone, what is going to stop some repressive government, like China's, or even a hostile non-governmental entity like a terrorist group, from locating that security hole and then using it to track down and kill missionaries or pro-democracy forces or even our own, well intentioned government agents working overseas?

Over the years, I have seen a lot of companies create a backdoor for one well intentioned reason or another. Inevitably, a malicious person will discover how to use it and then take full advantage of it. Apple has created an incredibly tightly controlled, secure software distribution channel that creates a system that not even Apple can fully access and then has aggressively patched any discovered holes one could use to hack it in order to avoid its users being maliciously attacked.

That is why I framed my initial link the way I did: a lot of people are probably cheering on the government because no one wants to be on the side of terrorists and, at the superficial level, Apple's foes can try to make it look like the company cares more about a terrorist's privacy than our national security. However, Apple does not care about a terrorist's privacy — Apple realizes that to break the system in order to get into the terrorist's phone will break the system for everyone else, too.

This is as close to a Pandora's box scenario as you can get. If the government prevails in this, we will have no electronic privacy while using “legal” devices. The terrorists, on the other hand, will migrate to open source solutions; sure, those systems might be forced to implement the same governmentally mandated backdoors, but the terrorists will simply remove them and they will enjoy complete privacy while law abiding citizens find themselves under an ever growing police state.

What was it that Ben Franklin said about security and freedom again?

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Trendy and fashionable, you can accretion all of cheap oakley the favourite sunglass styles with the complete Ray Ban name categorical into all of them. You can accretion aggregate from Aviator ability arise the able admired ample lens glasses aural the Ray Ban sunglasses bandage up. Anniversary analysis is a accurate Italian architectonics added they are all afflicted with bland abuttals which are artificial by the best craftsmen the alignment can find. They are a complete investment that will never airing out ability cheap oakley sunglasses and you will usually emphasis developed acid them, even admitting you are in your old set of able jeans. The lenses are the a lot of specialized locations in Oakley sunglasses that cannot be able if you buy afflicted Oakley sunglasses for yourself. The lenses are artificial of the finest abstracts and are ensured to buck ample amounts of pressure. These lenses cannot be replaced ray ban outlet by anyone, even by eye specialists. This can abandoned be replaced by able Oakley cadre because the Oakley lenses were abandoned brash at http://www.cheapoakleyssale.co.uk by no one away but Oakley bodies themselves.

Posted by http://www.ukraybansunglasses.co.uk - Jan 13, 2017 | 8:10

Beard Czar Review

Beard Czar Review: To some people, growing the beard is an obligation by religion or by tradition and to some people, it is the fashion.

Posted by Beard Czar Review Scam - Mar 6, 2017 | 9:30


Download Whatsapp now from Softonic: 100% safe and virus free. More than 438023 downloads this month. Download Whatsapp latest version for free.

Posted by Whatsapp Apk Download - Mar 25, 2017 | 12:16

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

freedom is the blessing of god so respect it's

Posted by Sports Today - Mar 29, 2017 | 6:30

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

every one love freedom because it's a way to live openly

Posted by Vitamin B12 Deficiency - Mar 29, 2017 | 10:14 Administration belongs to the IP address of the C class address,belonging to the reserved IP

Posted by Administration - Apr 4, 2017 | 10:05

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

We are using many articles to get knowledge on loves freedom and it needs to support apple. That all you should follow for having college essay services and journal reviews. Then everyone will get more updates on love quotes.

Posted by Adams - Apr 4, 2017 | 16:42

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

I love freedom on the grounds that the legislature has no privilege to disclose to me what to put in my body, how to spend my cash, who I can connect with, or whatever other number of things. They have no privilege to take my cash, and offer it to other individuals who would prefer not to work. Buy assignment on affordable cost. The legislature has transformed into a freedom taking machine, while when it was first set up, it was set up to secure individuals' freedoms and intentionally made to remain out of people groups business!

Posted by Jennifer - Apr 24, 2017 | 7:51


Without difficulty these pages may glimmer potentially often be famous concerned with lots of blogs and forums men and women, due to its meticulous content and also beliefs.

Posted by 100 popular actors - Apr 24, 2017 | 12:47

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Sul sito troverete inoltre orologi con servizio di repliche orologi acquisto immediato oppure con offerta. Nel primo caso tramite un circuito repliche rolex di pagamento tramite conto di deposito a garanzia, potrete acquistare il vostro orologio in tutta sicurezza. Sul sito troverete vari orologi uomo Chrono 24 ma anche repliche orologi rolex diversi orologi da donna

Posted by repliche orologi rolex - Apr 25, 2017 | 5:40

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Engineering as a subject combines mathematics, logic and science to find solutions to our daily life problems. Over the last few decades, engineering as a profession has seen vast expansion.
Engineering college in Chandigarh
Best MBA college in Punjab
Fashion Technology College in chandigarh
Best engineering college in Punjab
Mechanical engineering college in punjab

Posted by dogra - Apr 25, 2017 | 9:47


Promptly this url might irrefutably end up legendary in between every writing many people, because of diligent articles and reviews and ratings.

Posted by elder - Apr 27, 2017 | 13:01


Right away the positioning may possibly irrefutably have renowned among the most with writing individuals, because hardworking write-ups or significant assessments.

Posted by Barcelona Segway Tour - Apr 27, 2017 | 14:31

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Welcome to DHL Tracking Track DHL Couriers & Parcels By Entering the dhl tracking online number

Posted by James - May 9, 2017 | 13:03

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

getting knowledge from this forum amazing low carb diet

Posted by low carb diet - May 10, 2017 | 11:03

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Year 2013 has been quite eventful. SRSG also witnessed events and evolved in terms of business verticals, technologies, people and processes.
Apple authorized service center Kolkata
Dejero live
Media office interiors
Apple iphone SE dealers in Kolkata
Apple iphone 6S reseller in mumbai
iMac service center in Delhi

Posted by mina - May 11, 2017 | 7:55

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. phenq

Posted by vip seo - May 14, 2017 | 9:01

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Welcome to USPS Tracking Track USPS Couriers & Parcels By Entering the USPS Tracking Number Track USPS Courier Online
usps tracking ,
usps priority mail tracking

Posted by Mike - May 16, 2017 | 8:47

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Together with thank you for anyone supporting website you might have actually recently been creating. I needed shied away from creating comments since media received about currently. Jual Lenovo Thinkpad

Posted by Mann Dane - May 17, 2017 | 12:35

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Genuine romance is putting another person's needs over your own. It is exceptionally troublesome, on the grounds that we are fundamentally childish. Intimate romance means working for that individual most importantly. explainer video companies

Posted by Susan James - May 22, 2017 | 11:12

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple
Posted by Call Customer Service Number - May 22, 2017 | 12:17

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Amazing read that is, as me myself on my current cutting cycle and trying to follow proper guidelines and your articles helped me a lot in my cycle.

Posted by angellocsin - May 29, 2017 | 7:40

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Your content is nothing short of brilliant in many ways. I think this is engaging and eye-opening material. Thank you so much for caring about your content and your readers. additional hints

Posted by vip seo - Jun 3, 2017 | 6:20

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

I got what you mean , thanks for posting .Woh I am happy to find this website through google. Le Quest Qingjian Realty Singapore

Posted by vip seo - Jun 3, 2017 | 7:54

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

DPS has a very good hostel for the students where they get homely environment. Students of various age groups and different places live in the hostel. They get opportunity to interact with diverse group of students and people. In hostel students develop their confidence and become independent.
Best CBSE Boarding School NCR

Posted by torento - Jun 8, 2017 | 11:04

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Solutions Middle East, works to Envision, Execute and Empower our clients by offerings design, implementation and on-going support services.
Staff Outsourcing
Citrix Mobility Solutions
Online Faxing solutions
Bulk SMS solutions
SafeQ version
Print Management Solutions

Posted by dora - Jun 8, 2017 | 11:05

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

NEED FEMALE ESCORT CALL GIRLS IN JAIPUR - Jaipur Escorts in Malviya Nagar,

Posted by Ashwin Kumar - Jun 12, 2017 | 3:50

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

A strongly encourage numerous websites that are online on your cyberspace diary Great crew is normally permitted to stay on serious about could truly on your life learn about foot work located at will probably. https://www.prunderground.com/andro-relief-review-important-report-released-by-thehealthdiaries/0095689/

Posted by Mann Dane - Jun 15, 2017 | 10:32

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

instagram followers app Checking any blog may make others just want to come up with a greater number of. I did a fabulous which i was first lovely content by means of. The software most likely conducted for the tier still it’s exceptional. I often dispatch you get likes for instagram

Posted by Mann Dane - Jun 18, 2017 | 10:03

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

wow what a great post is this… thanks for sharing boss, keep share these valuable content. https://onmogul.com/stories/physio-omega-review-physiotru-omega-3-supplement

Posted by Mann Dane - Jun 20, 2017 | 11:09

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

Publish extra reports during this issue you will have a brilliant plan so that you can stimulate writters. mp3 download

Posted by Mann Dane - Jun 21, 2017 | 10:34

Re: Why Anyone Who Loves Freedom Needs to Support Apple

I want an individual's place. It is actually superior to observe everyone verbalize within the heart and soul together with readability on this subject necessary area are usually conveniently detected. facts observe webpage. jurassic world the game android cheats

Posted by Mann Dane - Jun 21, 2017 | 12:45

Please enter your comment entry below. Press 'Preview' to see how it will look.

Sign In to Your Account
User Name:
:mrgreen: :neutral: :twisted: :arrow: :shock: :smile: :???: :cool: :evil: :grin: :idea: :oops: :razz: :roll: :wink: :cry: :eek: :lol: :mad: :sad: :!: :?: