Internet, Ads and Writing

By Tim Butler | Posted at 22:42

A friend, who I'll let go nameless unless he wishes to identify himself, was having a spirited debate with me about Internet advertising. He remarked that it seemed to him site owners would prefer getting more hits over having fewer hits with advertising. It is an interesting idea, but I would suggest that it is an idea that is actually the same as the one that led to the Dot Com bubble and bust.

But, first, as I told him, the key principle for viewing ads — from a Christian standpoint — is that we are told the laborer is worth his wages (Luke 10.7, 1 Tim. 5.17-18). So fundamentally, for Christians, before we debate whether or not refusing to view ads is doing favors for the business owner, we ought to stop right here. Full stop, move along, there is nothing more to see here. It is only a legalistic, “find the loophole” view of things that allows us to say, “ads, oh, I didn't know that was a payment — surely I am not obligated to pay for services rendered to me!” The clear Christian principle is to pay for that which we receive. To deny a clear request for payment while enjoying the service rendered is simply wrong. And so, I try to practice this principle: if I find a site where I would need to remove the inline ads to be able to make use of it (because there are too many, or too many objectionable ones, etc.) I quit using the site. I've done so before, and will do so again.

That said, how is the business argument for overlooking people removing ads? Does it work? No. The flawed thinking here is based on the concept of “more eyeballs are better than profit.” Many early e-tailers worked on this principle selling products for massive losses purely to get more users. That could only work until they ran out of cash, then their companies died painful deaths.

The first rule of economics is simple: one produces a product up to but no farther than when marginal revenue equals marginal cost. If producing one more widget (or receiving one more visitor) means taking even the slightest loss, it doesn't make good sense to do so. If I can receive 2,000 visitors and make a profit, it is in no way better to get 10,000 and take a loss under normal circumstances. You are not doing Digg a favor by using their services if you never view their ads. They are better off without you, unless you happen to be Rush Limbaugh or Oprah and your endorsement is worth millions. Otherwise, do your favorite site on which you block ads a favor: quit using it.

No doubt, writers like to be read and will write sometimes for no cost simply for the thrill of having readers. Bloggers do this most certainly — though in large part my interest has more to do with interacting with my blogging friends. My own writings generally are not income generators, at least of any significance. But, on the other hand, most folks don't want to pay to be read. There are exceptions, for example, maybe I want you to read my site to sell my book, or my radio program, or what have you — but generally the question would be why would I pay you to read my work? Would I pay you to eat my culinary creation? Drive my car? Live in my house?

Yes, you as the reader pay for your Internet, but nearly every provider you deal with is paying more than you are. They are paying for redundant connections, power generators, backup storage, professional IT staffers and of course developers and writers of the services you enjoy — far more than the little $14.95 a month you pay for Internet access. And, remember: you are the one that wants to use Digg or MySpace (incidentally, I use the former little and the latter not at all), so it only makes sense that you are the one to foot the bill. That is how capitalism is suppose to work: the one who wants something pays for it. Put bluntly, if it costs you a little or a lot is your problem, not the provider's.

And so, as always, I present my challenge to those who wish to do the morally right thing but despise ads. Quit viewing sites with ads. Typically people making such an argument say the Internet was better before ads. Fine, maybe it was; let's find out by having you only use ad-free sites. Don't forget, that means no Google. Have fun. If you like it that way, keep at it and everyone is happy. If you do not, well, then, can you really complain about the ads?


Re: Internet, Ads and Writing

I have no problem with header and sidebar adds (provided they're not of “objectionable content”. I see them much like TV commercials. I don't like pop-up adds, and that mostly for the hassle of having to shut them down one at a time…and the fact some piece of code is telling my computer to open more browser windows….sorta creeps me out.

Posted by Jason P. Franklin - Aug 5, 2008 | 6:19

Re: Internet, Ads and Writing

I understand this is your blog and all but to present only your side of the coin while leaving all of my opinions unvoiced seems a bit slanted to say the least. If you really wish for an open debate to occur then it would seem only Christian of you to present the entire scope of the discussion and not just the points which support your stance.

Posted by Mark - Aug 5, 2008 | 17:06

Re: Internet, Ads and Writing

Jason: I agree. I do block pop-ups/unders; I figure what's on the page is fine, but there is no need to go any farther. I really wish they had never come up with the idea of pop up windows — their usefulness seems vastly outweighed by their problems.

Mark: I wouldn't cite your opinions in detail without your permission first. It has nothing to do with being Christian or not, though. I only wanted to reply to one point (the economic one) and I omitted any identifiable information so as not to link you to it. I do think I conveyed the gist of it though, which was, “why wouldn't site owners want more eyeballs,” was it not? If it was not, then feel free to post what it was, because clearly I did not understand it.

Posted by Timothy R. Butler - Aug 6, 2008 | 5:06

Re: Internet, Ads and Writing

I need your resources for having internet, ads and online essay writing journal articles. That all we are getting to understood the online essay writing service review books and content books. Thanks for sharing your educational posts for the college students.

Posted by Manley - Jun 23, 2017 | 4:37

Re: Internet, Ads and Writing

This article we are using to find journal reviews and updates on this http://findessayservices.com website. So we are chosen your great resources and assignments for helping the users and thanks to all of them.

Posted by asdf - Jul 10, 2017 | 3:39

Re: Internet, Ads and Writing

Today I am better understand the principle of advertising, think also very interesting,…Bluetooth in ear headphones

Posted by Jennifer phan - Sep 6, 2017 | 0:58

phd thesis writing services


I read this article. I think You put a lot of effort to create this article. I appreciate your work.
PhD Thesis Writing Services

Posted by words Doctorate - Nov 22, 2017 | 5:06

Re: Internet, Ads and Writing

Words Kshetra is offering International Business Services for expand business on
International Business Platform.

Posted by International Business expansion - Nov 28, 2017 | 8:54

Escort Girls in Delhi Hotels

Finally got an Impressive article to read. I am so delighted to have this kind article that is awesome for me. Thanks for this wonderful article
Escort Girls in Delhi Hotels

Posted by Escort Girls in Delhi Hotels - Dec 4, 2017 | 10:34

Please enter your comment entry below. Press 'Preview' to see how it will look.

Name:
Sign In to Your Account
User Name:
Password:
Location:
Homepage:
E-mail:
Subject:
:mrgreen: :neutral: :twisted: :arrow: :shock: :smile: :???: :cool: :evil: :grin: :idea: :oops: :razz: :roll: :wink: :cry: :eek: :lol: :mad: :sad: :!: :?: